Closing the Door on Einstein and Bohr’s Quantum Debate
Quantum mechanics makes extraordinarily accurate predictions, but has internal workings so counter-intuitive that many refuse to believe they represent reality. Among these non-believers was Albert Einstein, who, starting in 1927, carried on an extended debate with Niels Bohr, a towering figure in quantum theory. In 1935 Einstein argued for the creation of a theory that was compatible with both the Theory of Relativity, in which the speed of light is a fundamental limit, and with realism, the idea that our observations reflect a reality independent of ourselves. This position, now called “local realism,” directly opposed Bohr's arguments for the uncertainty principle. The debate between these two giants of physics was never settled. In 1964, CERN researcher John Stuart Bell showed that an experiment could resolve this seemingly philosophical question. Bell analyzed the following scenario: pairs of particles are sent to widely-separated measurement stations, where one property of each particle is measured. The measurements are chosen randomly and performed simultaneously. If the particles show sufficiently well-correlated behaviour, Bell proved, something in local realism must be wrong: Either the particle properties had no prior existence, or particles can communicate with each other faster than light (or both). Starting in 1972, a sequence of experiments have approximated Bell's scenario with increasing sophistication. Until this year, however, all experiments contained weaknesses, or “loopholes,” allowing alternate explanations. For example: not performing the measurements fast enough, not measuring enough of the particles, or not choosing sufficiently randomly. This year, three experiments: at TU Delft, IQOQI (Vienna), and NIST (USA), succeeded in simultaneously closing all of the closable loopholes, and in doing so solidly rejected local realism.
This work was the result of three collaborations: TU Delft - ICREA - ICFO - Element 6, IQOQI - U. Vienna - MQP - Linköpings U. - ICREA - ICFO - PTB - NIST, and NIST - IQC - U. Illinois - U. Moncton - JQI - JPL - ICREA - ICFO - CIAR